For those who don’t know me, I am a tech junkie. A technoholic as I used to say during the TechnologyEvangelist.com days. When new technology comes out, I grab it, learn it and decide if I want to keep it or not. This holds true of smartphones as well.
I own or have owned several smartphones: HTC Evo, HTC Nexus One, Apple iPhone 3G, 3G S, and 4, Blackberry 8800, Palm Pre, etc., etc. For a couple of years I used the iPhone as it was the best smartphone on the market. Alas, it looks like Android has caught up.
The problem with Android is that there are several key things it doesn’t do as well as it should. Scrolling is not as smooth as it should be. While the browser is based on Webkit just like the iPhone, it is not as good as the iPhone browser at detecting what you want to zoom in to. Basically it comes down to the idea that the iOS is more polished than Android, but Android is more usable than iOS.
Whaaa?
For weeks now I have been trying to figure out how to put in to words why I prefer Android. Heck, I wasn’t even sure myself. I decided to run a couple of tests. The first test was to carry both the HTC Evo and the iPhone 4 with me at the same time and see which one I would grab when I needed to do something. I would switch which pocket each phone was in every day to ensure this wasn’t muscle memory that I was observing. The result: nearly every time I wanted to do something I went for the Evo and not the iPhone. The next test was to leave the Evo at home and use only the iPhone. See what it was about the Evo that I liked so much but could not put in to words. The result surprised me a bit.
When forced to use just the iPhone I found myself changing how I perform even the most basic actions to get around some pretty serious flaws in the iPhone workflow. For example, I can’t perform many bulk actions on e-mail such as ‘Mark Read’ so I found I would move the e-mail to another folder, wait until I got to my Webmail client, move the messages back while marking them as read. Otherwise my Inbox would read something like 800 new messages even though I really only had 12. When working with SMS alerts, I would send 3 alerts for urgent items. Since I can’t add my own SMS Alert Tones without jailbreaking the iPhone, and even then I don’t believe I can have a different tone for each contact, I was forced to change how I deal with SMS alerts and messages as well. There are usability issues like these all over iOS, which I didn’t even realize were there until I started using Android.
I have found that on my Nexus One and Evo I change the device to work with how I want to use the phone. With the iPhone it is the other way around. I change how I work to allow the device to be used at all. At the end of the day that’s why I prefer my Evo, it does what I want and not the other way around.
This is not to say that the iPhone is not a great device. The iPhone 4, even more than the 3G S, is smooth like silk. Every action is just fast, responsive and does exactly what you would think. On the Evo you have HTC Sense in your way. HTC makes some amazing hardware, but they really suck at software. They seem to think they know better than Google on usability but alas, they are very, very wrong. It takes a lot of hacking around to make an Evo battery last a full day and to get the interface to become responsive. Heck, I rooted my phone and just installed a stock version of Android which basically fixed all of the faults in the Evo. Just waiting on Android 2.2 which should make the Evo just as smooth as the iPhone 3G S, but probably not as smooth as the iPhone 4.
My point is, Android works for me because I was able to make it work. If you’re not that geeky and don’t want to spend the time to make the device truly fit your workflow, iPhone is probably for you. If instead you want a device that answers to you and not the other way around then Android is for you. Either way, it is great to see Google stepping up and giving iOS a real run for its money.




